Analysis and Reading: Use of a reasoning skill to organize and structure the argument

⭐️ Crafting a structured argument is crucial. Dive deep into the nuances of using reasoning skills to enhance your writing and make your arguments stand out!

📜 Analysis and Reasoning: Historical Reasoning

What does an Argument Consist of?

• A good argument requires structure, necessitating one of the course reasoning skills to create that structure. You can choose whichever skill works best for a particular prompt: causation, comparison, or continuity and change over time.

How do I know if my reasoning is good?

• Strong reasoning goes throughout an essay, so this will be the overarching structure of your writing from the thesis through your body paragraphs.
• The reasoning doesn’t necessarily have to be completely balanced or even in order to count, which gives you room to write about what you know best. For example, in an essay structured around continuity and change, you might spend most of your time addressing changes and relatively little time addressing continuity. And that’s ok.
• The best essays do address both “sides” of the historical reasoning, and yours should too. If you created a complex thesis in your introduction, you can extend those ideas into your body paragraphs. Even if you don’t have equal sentences or paragraphs for each topic, as long as you address the reasoning process in your essay, you’re on the right track.

Reasoning Skills:

• Causation: When focusing on causation, delve deep into the roots of an event. What led up to it? Was it inevitable? Which factors were dominant, and which played a minor role?
  • Example: Choose this when a prompt asks about the reasons behind a specific event.
• Comparison: Comparisons shed light on similarities and differences. But it's more than just listing them out. Analyze the implications of these similarities and differences. What do they reveal about the societies, events, or phenomena you're comparing?
  • Example: Ideal for prompts asking for an analysis of two different, yet related events or periods.
• Continuity and Change Over Time: This isn't just about pinpointing what changed or remained the same. Dive into the nuances. What were the catalysts for the changes? Why did certain things remain unaffected? How did these continuities and changes impact the broader historical context?
  • Example: Use this when the prompt is about the evolution or persistence of certain aspects over a period.

Courtesy of Nora

🛎️ Selecting the Right Reasoning Skill

• Every historical prompt comes with its own unique flavor. Thus, depending on the nuances of the question, you might lean towards causation (unraveling the 'why' behind events), comparison (contrasting and juxtaposing entities/events), or continuity and change over time (decoding the transformations and constants over a timeline).
• But how do you ascertain that your choice hits the bullseye? The strength of your reasoning should cascade throughout your essay, crafting a cohesive thread from the introduction to the conclusion.
• Remember, perfection doesn’t always equate to balance. You might pivot more towards changes and brush over continuities, or vice versa. This choice is not a sign of weakness; instead, it shows you're strategizing based on your strengths.
• Nevertheless, aim to touch upon both dimensions of your chosen reasoning skill. Even if you veer more towards one side, ensuring a nod to the other aspect accentuates the depth and comprehensiveness of your argument.

💎 Elevate Your Argument

1. 🎯 Crafting a Complex Thesis: Root your essay in a thesis that's not just a statement but a promise of a journey. This thesis should be a preview of the intricate tapestry of ideas you're about to weave.
2. 🤓 Integrating Ideas: As you venture into the body of your essay, ensure a seamless flow. Ideas should not just follow one another; they should converse, contest, and converge.
3. 📚 Evidence Selection: While it’s pivotal to have a wealth of information, discernment in choosing the most impactful evidence amplifies your argument's potency. Each piece of evidence should not just support but elevate your argument.
4. 🪄 Concluding with a Punch: Your conclusion is not just a summary. It's the final note that resonates, the crescendo of your symphony. Ensure it leaves an impression, encapsulating the essence of your argument and its significance.

💡 Pro Tip: Practice makes perfect. Regularly engage with diverse historical prompts. Experiment with different reasoning skills. Over time, you’ll develop an intuitive knack for selecting the best strategy for any given topic.